Guns, Hollywood & the Colorado Massacre

Guns, Hollywood & the Colorado Massacre

I was in Colorado the week James Holmes walked into an Aurora movie theatre, showing The Dark Night Rises and allegedly murdered 12 and injured 58 people with an assault rifle. With hair dyed red he apparently modeled himself on the film’s sadistic villain – The Joker. The aftermath has reawakened the debate about gun control in a country where there are 88 guns for every 100 people.

What fewer people are talking about is the role of violent stories in all of this. Some Hollywood executives have claimed that violent entertainment actually reduces aggression by providing a cathartic outlet. Yet at least a hundred studies have conclusively demonstrated the opposite. Screen violence increases aggression particularly in children where it often induces copycat behaviour. Of course stories affect our actions, if they didn’t why would companies spend billions on the short sales stories we call adverts?

In my book The Astonishing Power of Story I explain just why stories are so powerful. You know how sometimes when you’re watching a film or reading a book you feel as if you’re the hero? That has to do with a part of the brain called the Mirror Neuron Network. You watch someone hit their finger with a hammer and you wince, that’s another example of how the mirror neurons internalize others’ experience as if it is our own. With our mirror neurons we don’t just watch stories, we live them and that can change us when we go back to our own lives. We’re not robots, we’re not going to act out everything that we see but if we’ve just “mirrored” a character successfully solving a problem with aggression, we may become primed to see aggression as a solution to our own problems. Stories provide virtual role models that can be a catalyst for bad or good. They certainly can do a lot of good.

President Ronald Reagan credited a fictional Hollywood movie called The Day After for changing his mind on nuclear war policy and leading to the destruction of nearly 3000 nuclear weapons. The film Pay it Forward led to a major philanthropic foundation that has funded hundreds of projects supporting schools and hospitals besides spurring countless random acts of kindness. Audiences of the The Kite Runner paid for 70 rural libraries and 500 laptops in Afghanistan. Blood Diamond propelled the diamond industry to educate consumers on conflict-free diamonds. These were all fictional stories that spurred people to take positive action.

Using the power of story, my new book Quest, Inc. seeks to inspire and equip readers to improve their lives. I’m currently in Hollywood meeting with producers to turn the book into a television drama series. Sure, all those cop, lawyer and police dramas can be fun by why not a show about the high end coaches who change people’s lives? If we’re going to watch drama wouldn’t we be better off “mirroring” characters taking heroic action to improve their lives?

James Holmes, the man who modeled himself on the Joker, never shot up an Aurora theatre because he watched a Batman film. That would negate his responsibility. But study after study suggests that it probably contributed. So, as writers and producers what stories are we going to create, and as readers and viewers, what stories are we going to entertain?

/ Blog Posts

Share the Post

About the Author

Comments (4)

  1. Justin Cohen :

    Thank you for your positive feedback Jed! You might enjoy this too from Laurens van der Post: “The story was the
    bushman’s most sacred possession. These people knew what we do not; that without a story you have not got a nation, or culture, or civilization. Without a story of your own, you haven’t got a life of your own.”

  2. Jed Diamond :

    Justin, As a therapist for more than 40 years, I know the power of stories and the potential for positive change that healing stories can provide. Thanks for your book, Quest Inc. Its the best kind of “self help” book we can have. Your work reminds me of the great story teller Laurens van der Post, writing about the people of Africa. He quotes a native man who is in prison for stealing food. “I am here in a great city and I do not obtain stories. I do merely listen, watching for a story which I want to hear; that it may float into my ear…I will go to sit at my home that I may listen, turn my ears backwards to the heels of my feet on which I wait, so that I can feel that a story is in the wind.”

    We hunger for stories even more than food. Keep them them coming.

  3. Justin :

    Couldn’t agree more Janet, I believe we all have a responsibility to contribute to the good, and stories have a powerful role to play.

  4. Janet :

    I really like your line of reasoning and am not in favour of children watching violent movies at all, whether or not they have happy endings. I sincerely hope movie producers can find a way to make movies that will, as you say, help make a better life for all of us.